
Tomato Soup
London, United Kingdom · View all recipes
Overview
Fresh tomatoes cooked with onion, cloves and stock, passed through a food mill, and thickened with a browned roux. No country is claimed; this is the classic European cream-of-tomato construction. The roux is what distinguishes it from most modern tomato soups, which are simply blended and finished with cream. Cooking butter and flour together until the mixture turns a medium brown, then whisking the tomato mixture into it gradually, gives body and a faint toasted depth that blending alone does not produce. It is an older technique and it is worth knowing. Two details are easy to overlook and both matter. The whole cloves, four of them, in a soup this size, are a distinctly old-fashioned touch that gives the soup a warm, faintly medicinal background note; they are removed with everything else by the food mill. And the two teaspoons of sugar are not there to sweeten but to counteract the acidity of the tomatoes, which is why the source says to taste and adjust. Passing the soup through a food mill rather than a blender leaves skins and seeds behind and gives a smoother, cleaner result. A sieve does the same job with more effort. Africa has its own tomato-based dishes in quantity, obe ata, shakshuka, matbucha, but they are stews and salads rather than soups, and they are separate pages here.
Ingredients
Directions
- 1
Combine the tomatoes, onion, cloves and chicken broth in a stockpot over medium heat.
- 2
Bring to the boil and cook gently for about 20 minutes so the flavours come together.
- 3
Take the pot off the heat and pass the mixture through a food mill into a large bowl or pan. Discard whatever stays behind, this is what removes the skins, seeds and cloves and gives a clean texture.
- 4
In the now-empty stockpot, melt the butter over medium heat.
- 5
Mix in the flour to make a roux and cook until it turns a medium brown. This browning is what gives the soup its body and a faint toasted depth.
- 6
Whisk in a little of the tomato mixture at a time so no lumps form, then work in the rest.
- 7
Season with the sugar and salt, taste and adjust. The sugar is there to balance the acidity of the tomatoes rather than to sweeten the soup.
Africook’s Notes
- Cook the roux to a medium brown. A pale roux thickens but adds nothing; a browned one gives depth.
- Whisk the tomato mixture in gradually. Poured in all at once it lumps and cannot be recovered.
- Use a food mill rather than a blender if you have one. It leaves skins and seeds behind and the texture is noticeably cleaner.
- The sugar is balancing acidity, not sweetening. Taste before adding the full two teaspoons.
- Four whole cloves is more than it sounds. They are strong, and they are meant to be a background note rather than a flavour you identify.
- Use vegetable stock and it becomes vegetarian, which the chicken broth otherwise prevents.
Reviews
Be the first to rate this recipe
Cooked it? Your rating helps the next person decide whether to try it.
No reviews on this one yet. If you have cooked it, yours would be the first.



